(AP) LOS ANGELES – Six members of a Navy special forces unit and two Navy wives sued The Associated Press on Tuesday, saying the news agency endangered the servicemen’s lives and invaded their privacy by publishing photos showing the men interacting with Iraqi prisoners.
The lawsuit says the agency erred by not obscuring the identity of the six SEALs in photos that accompanied a story distributed worldwide earlier this month, contending publication of the photos jeopardizes future covert operations and harms the servicemen’s careers.
“There was no need for the AP to publish the faces of the SEALs,” James W. Huston, an attorney representing the plaintiffs, said in a press release. “In fact, the SEALs showed more respect for the insurgents and terrorists that they were apprehending by obscuring their faces than the AP did for the Navy SEALs who were in Iraq risking their lives.”
The story was written by San Diego reporter Seth Hettena, who is named as a defendant. The story did not name the Navy members or the wife who posted the photos on what she believed was a private Web site.
“We believe that none of the claims have any solid basis in the law as we understand it,” said Dave Tomlin, AP’s assistant general counsel. “We intend to defend ourselves and our reporter vigorously and, we expect, successfully.”
The lawsuit, filed in San Diego County Superior Court, states that Hettena took the photos from a Navy wife’s “personal digital photo album without notice or permission.” It says that the woman, identified only as “Jane Doe,” believed the nearly 1,800 photos she posted on the Internet site were protected from access by unauthorized users and required a password to view.
The initial AP story, transmitted Dec. 3, noted that the photos were found on the commercial photo-sharing Web site Smugmug.com using the search engine Google, and were not password-protected until after the reporter purchased copies online and began inquiries.
The story said the photos appear to show Navy SEALs in Iraq sitting on hooded and handcuffed detainees and also what appear to be bloodied prisoners, one with a gun to his head. It noted that the Navy had launched a formal investigation into the photographs after being shown them by an AP reporter, adding that the photos did not necessarily depict any illegal activities.
The AP later reported that the Navy’s preliminary findings showed most of the 15 photos transmitted by the agency were taken for legitimate intelligence-gathering purposes and showed commandos using approved procedures.
The AP noted that the Navy has expanded its investigation into additional photos, however, a process that could take up to a month and result in disciplinary action.
The lawsuit asks for unspecified damages, including punitive damages, and a preliminary injunction barring the AP from further use of the photos and requiring the agency to protect the SEALs’ identities.
It contends that at least two wives of the SEALs pictured have received daily harassing and threatening phone calls since the photos were published, and alleges intentional infliction of emotional distress.
Taylor Clark, a spokesman for Naval Special Warfare Command, declined comment on the suit, calling it a private matter.
http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=533&e=6&u=/ap/20041229/ap_on_re_us/seals_photos_lawsuit
I agree, reporters and new agencies should be held liable for these kinds of circumstances. One simple solution is to ban them from being attached to SF type units (which was not the case here).
On the other hand, dependants and service members need to keep their personal photos off the freaking web! If you don’t understand what you are doing then you shouldn’t be doing it. The web is a public place period… passwords or not, your content may very well be seen.
The following is from the site of photo theft, and contains some of the terms of use. The phoney "reporter" did not "purchase" the photos, he perhaps purchased "access as a client" to the site. The SEALS’ lawyer needs to sue AP into the next solar system for multiple instances (probably hundreds, if not thousands) of copyright infringement. Each copyright offense (if i remember correctly) generates about $160,000.00 in punitive before actual damages even begin to compute:
http://www.smugmug.com/aboutus/terms.mg
COPYRIGHT
All content included on this site, such as text, graphics, logos, icons, images, photographs, audio clips, video clips, digital downloads, data compilations, and software, is the property of smugmug, or its subscribers who upload photographs or other media, or its content and software suppliers and is protected by United States and international copyright laws. smugmug’s selection, coordination and arrangement of all content on this site is the exclusive property of smugmug, and is protected as a compilation by U.S. and international copyright laws. All software used on this site or in conjunction with the Services is the property of smugmug or its software suppliers and is protected by United States and international copyright laws.
LICENSE AND SITE ACCESS
smugmug grants you a limited license to access and make personal use of this site but not to download (other than page caching) or modify it or any portion of it, except with the express written consent of smugmug, inc. This license does not include any resale or commercial use of this site or its contents. This site or any portion of this site may not be reproduced, duplicated, copied, sold, resold, visited, or otherwise exploited for any commercial purpose without express written consent of smugmug, inc. Any unauthorized use terminates the permission or license granted by smugmug.
LICENSE GRANTED BY USERS
smugmug does not claim ownership in the photographs, videos or other media created or uploaded by Subscribers ("Media"). smugmug will not resell Media to third parties. Unless we indicate otherwise, if you upload Content, including any Media, to the smugmug site, you grant smugmug a nonexclusive, royalty-free right to publish, distribute and display the Content as we deem appropriate in providing the Services authorized or requested by you, including the right to use the name that is submitted in connection with such Content. You further understand and agree that, in order to help ensure smooth operation of our system, we may keep backup copies of Content indefinitely.
You represent and warrant that you own or otherwise control all of the rights to the Content (including without limitation Media) that you post; that use of the Content you supply does not violate these Terms of Use and will not cause injury to any person or entity; and that you will indemnify smugmug for all claims resulting from Content you supply. smugmug has the right but not the obligation to monitor and edit or remove any activity or Content. You understand and agree that smugmug takes no responsibility and assumes no liability for any Content posted by you or any third party
COPYRIGHT COMPLAINTS
smugmug respects the intellectual property rights of others. If you believe that your work has been copied in a way that constitutes copyright infringement, please contact smugmug’s agent for notice of claims of copyright or other intellectual property infringement ("Agent"), at copyrightagent@smugmug.com or Copyright Agent, smugmug, 248 Walker Drive, #8, Mountain View, CA 94043.
************
So there you go, AP sure as the devil would not want me on the jury when this goes before the bar! 😡